If – some day in the future – I find myself standing in the corner of a smoky room at 2am in the morning, music blaring from a not-too-distant corner and drink in hand, and someone from the group of very passionately conversational party goers I was surrounded by ventured to ask, “Okay…..so who do you think is the greatest pop music group of all time?”, I would, without hesitation, argue that no band in the history of pop music was as good at pop music as those four sparkly jumpsuit-wearing Swedes from the 1970s known as ABBA.
You might argue back, but I wouldn’t be listening. After all, that music’s really loud….and it gets harder to hear you the further away I walk from whatever you’re saying about NSync.
Sure, I realize that in some circles expressing an appreciation for ABBA can pretty much kill any street cred or cool points you might have built up over time, plunging you quicky from the in-crowd to the down-and-out, but I just can’t fathom saying that any other group in history has been more important to furthering the cause of well-crafted pop songs. Everyone always trips all over themselves touting the songwriting prowess of the Fab Four from Liverpool, but what about the Fab Four from Stockholm?
Benny Andersson, Bjorn Ulvaeus, Agnetha Faltskog, and Anni-Frid Lyngstad represent, to me, one of the rarest of all musical things: that perfect moment in time of synergy where the right people come together at the right time with the right blend of talents and create something unimaginably special and perfect. Take even one away, and the whole thing falls apart like a poorly-played game of Jenga.
Or…..does it?
I would never have thought it possible, but recently I discovered something that made me rethink this long-held position. While, upon much reflection, I still feel ABBA was a once-in-a-lifetime melding of four unique musicians which provided for some of the finest pop music this side of Jonkoping, I now have some very compelling evidence that perhaps the songs might still have been as strong with a vocalist or two changed out.
Ladies and gentlemen…..exhibit A: a brand new ABBA song from 2009!
Okay, okay, so you caught me in a lie….it’s not really new ABBA. But seriously, how could anyone tell??? It’s ALL there: the beautiful melody, the soaring vocals (provided courtesy of a lovely and talented singer named Helen Sjöholm), the lush harmonies, the majestic piano accents, the amazing arrangement, the clever little bits of counterpoint sneaking in and out.
The first time I heard this song, “Story Of A Heart” from Benny Andersson’s 2009 solo release of the same name, I was flabbergasted. How could this be, I wondered? Were the other three members of ABBA that inconsequential? This would fit perfectly on any of ABBA’s eight official releases, but here it is twenty years later and Agnetha and Anni-Frid are nowhere in sight.
Bjorn, on the other hand….
Okay, so apparently pop songcraft of this magnitude takes two: Bjorn wrote the English language lyrics to the song. Actually, now that I’m going down this path, it seems like it’s always taken two, doesn’t it? Page and Plant, Lennon and McCartney, Simon and Garfunkel, Rogers and Hammerstein, John and Taupin, Jam and Lewis, Gershwin and Gershwin…songwriting duos have long been a fixture in the music industry, and it’s never really been a set formula as to how that whole thing works. Sometimes one writes the lyrics and the other the melody. Sometimes both write both together. Sometimes one writes everything but needs the other to elevate the final product to a new level. You can’t really pin down the magic of the best songwriting pairs, but what you do know is that the result of that collaboration will be fabulous.
So it is with Andersson and Ulvaeus. The songwriting team behind the slick pop stylings of ABBA, they kept going as a team after the group broke up in 1982, jumping right back into the game and writing the score to the smash stage musical “Chess” (which itself managed one nice little top 40 hit back in 1984, “One Night In Bangkok” by Murray Head…..and how often do Broadway songs hit the top 40, I ask you?). More songwriting projects followed, none of which really garnering much attention here in the United States, but keeping the two friends busy nonetheless. One of my favorites is this clever little pop tune from 1993’s “Shapes” by Josefin Nilsson, a Swedish singer and actress. All songs on her debut album? Written by Benny and Bjorn.
(Quick sidebar and interesting fact: did you know that ABBA has, to this day, never officially broken up? Just like North and South Korea are technically still at war because of lack of an official signed peace treaty, ABBA never officially announced their dissolution, and actually mentioned in separate interviews throughout 1983 and 1984 that they planned on eventually coming back together for another album. Of course, as we all know, that never happened….)
Still, as good as their output has remained over the years, nothing I’ve heard can quite match “Story Of A Heart” for its sheer……umm…..ABBA-ness? I’m truly amazed how effortless Benny and Bjorn make writing a great pop song seem every time I listen to it, and it makes me wonder if things would somehow be just as magical as they were back in the 70s if there ever were a reunion.
Of course, let’s keep in mind that all four members were offered a billion dollars (yes, you read that right….”billion” with a “b”) to reunite for a limited tour about ten years ago and they refused, so…..I wouldn’t hold my breath if I were you.